Scribe logoScribeNotes & practice
Sign inStart free
  1. Notes
  2. ›IB Environmental Systems and Societies
  3. ›HL HL lenses
  4. ›HL.b Environmental economics

IB Environmental Systems and Societies · Topic HL · HL lenses

HL.b Environmental economics

Explain how externalities distort markets, compare taxes, permits and regulation, and evaluate economic tools for sustainability.

  • 5 min read
  • 5 parts
  • 10 questions
  • Draft
  • HL only
Start a Quick 5 on this topic→Jump to the 10 questions
1/5Markets can ignore costs that fall on other people
  1. 1Markets can ignore costs that fall on other people
  2. 2Social cost is private cost plus the external cost
  3. 3Taxes, permits and subsidies change the price signal
  4. 4Regulation sets limits directly instead of using prices
  5. 5Economic tools have strengths but also clear limits
  6. Check your recall
  7. Practice: 10 questions
1

Part 1 of 5: Markets can ignore costs that fall on other people

A factory sells goods at a price that covers its wages, materials and energy. It does not pay for the smoke that settles on nearby homes. That damage is a real cost, but someone else carries it.

An externality is a cost or benefit of an activity that reaches people who did not choose it. Air pollution is a negative externality because it harms others. A privately owned woodland that cleans the air is a positive externality, because neighbours gain.

Because the producer ignores the harm, the market price is too low. Too much of the product is made. Society then pays through ill health, damaged ecosystems and lost resources.

Key term

externality

An externality is a cost or benefit of an economic activity that is borne by people who are neither buyers nor sellers.

Part 1 done

2

Part 2 of 5: Social cost is private cost plus the external cost

Now that harm outside the market is clear, it helps to measure it. The private cost is what the producer pays to make a good. The external cost is the harm borne by others.

Adding the two gives the social cost, the true cost of the activity to society. A fair price would show this full amount. Making the polluter pay for the harm is called internalising the externality.

Figure 1. Social cost lies above private cost, so the market output is higher than the output that suits society.

In the graph, the market settles where demand meets private cost. Society would do better at the lower output where demand meets social cost.

Key terms · tap one for its definition

private cost

A private cost is the cost paid directly by a producer or consumer for a good or activity.

social cost

The social cost of an activity is its private cost plus the external costs imposed on other people.

internalising

Internalising an externality means making the producer or consumer pay its external cost so that the cost enters the price.

Part 2 done

Quick check

One question on the part you just read

Easy

Identify the situation that is a negative externality.
Show answer and explanation

Answer: B · Worked explanation

A negative externality is a harm that falls on people who are not part of the transaction. The fishery bears the damage and is not paid for it. The higher fertiliser price is an ordinary production cost already paid by the farm, so it is not an externality.
3

Part 3 of 5: Taxes, permits and subsidies change the price signal

If the price is wrong, the simplest fix is to change it. A pollution tax charges the producer for each unit of pollution or polluting product. When the tax equals the external cost, the producer pays the full social cost.

A cap-and-trade system works differently. The government sets a limit on total pollution and issues permits that firms can buy and sell. The cap fixes the quantity, and the market sets the price of a permit.

A subsidy rewards good behaviour instead of punishing bad behaviour. A grant for solar panels lowers the price of a clean option.

Worked example

Setting a tax equal to the external cost

A paper mill’s waste causes 4 currency units (cu) of harm for each tonne of paper made. It makes 500 tonnes in a month. Find the tax per tonne that internalises the harm, and the total tax for the month.
  1. 1
    Set the tax per tonne equal to the external cost per tonne, so the tax is 4 cu tonne−14\,\mathrm{cu\,tonne^{-1}}4cutonne−1.
  2. 2
    Write the word equation: total tax = tax per tonne ×\times× tonnes made.
  3. 3
    Substitute: 4 cu tonne−1×500 tonne4\,\mathrm{cu\,tonne^{-1}}\times500\,\mathrm{tonne}4cutonne−1×500tonne.
  4. 4
    Calculate: 4×500=20004\times500=20004×500=2000.

Answer: The tax is 4 cu tonne−14\,\mathrm{cu\,tonne^{-1}}4cutonne−1, so the mill pays 2000 cu2000\,\mathrm{cu}2000cu in the month.

Key terms · tap one for its definition

pollution tax

A pollution tax is a charge placed on each unit of pollution or polluting product, which raises its price.

cap-and-trade

Cap-and-trade is a system that limits total emissions and lets firms buy and sell permits to emit within that limit.

subsidy

A subsidy is a payment or price reduction from a government that makes a desired activity cheaper.

Part 3 done

4

Part 4 of 5: Regulation sets limits directly instead of using prices

Governments can also skip the price and set rules. Regulation, often called command-and-control, sets legal limits or bans. Examples are emission limits, protected areas and bans on harmful chemicals.

Market-based tools compared with regulation

FeatureMarket-based toolsRegulation
How it worksChanges the price of pollutionSets legal limits or bans
FlexibilityFirms choose their cheapest way to cut pollutionEvery firm must meet the same rule
Certainty of resultLess certain for taxes, as firms may pay and carry on; a cap fixes the totalMore certain if enforced well
Public moneyTaxes and permit sales raise revenueEnforcement costs money
Best suited toMany polluters with varied costsSevere or irreversible harm
Feature
How it works
Market-based tools
Changes the price of pollution
Regulation
Sets legal limits or bans
Feature
Flexibility
Market-based tools
Firms choose their cheapest way to cut pollution
Regulation
Every firm must meet the same rule
Feature
Certainty of result
Market-based tools
Less certain for taxes, as firms may pay and carry on; a cap fixes the total
Regulation
More certain if enforced well
Feature
Public money
Market-based tools
Taxes and permit sales raise revenue
Regulation
Enforcement costs money
Feature
Best suited to
Market-based tools
Many polluters with varied costs
Regulation
Severe or irreversible harm

Regulation suits harm that is severe or cannot be undone, because a clear ban is safer than a price. Taxes and permits suit cases where firms differ widely in how cheaply they can cut pollution. Many governments use both.

Exam tip

When comparing, name the same feature for both approaches, such as flexibility. Link them with a word like whereas.

Key term

regulation

Regulation is the use of laws and enforced limits to control environmental harm directly rather than through prices.

Part 4 done

Quick check

One question on the part you just read

Easy

State what it means to internalise an externality.
Show answer and explanation

Answer: A · Worked explanation

Internalising means the producer or consumer pays the external cost, so the price shows the social cost. Paying the people harmed from public money does not change the producer’s price. A ban removes the product instead of correcting its price.
5

Part 5 of 5: Economic tools have strengths but also clear limits

No tool is perfect, so each one needs to be judged. Economic tools have clear strengths.

  • They give firms a continuing reason to cut pollution.
  • They let firms find the cheapest way to do so.
  • Taxes and permit sales raise public money for restoration.

They also have weaknesses. Valuing natural capital is hard, because many benefits, such as beauty, have no market price. A wrongly set tax or a generous cap may change little.

  • Costs may fall hardest on poorer households.
  • Paying a price can seem to make the damage acceptable.

Exam tip

In an evaluation, give a strength and a weakness. Then judge when the tool works best.

Go deeperChoosing between a tax and a cap

A tax fixes the price of pollution but not the amount released. A cap fixes the amount but lets the permit price vary.

If limiting harm is urgent, a cap gives more certainty. If keeping costs steady matters more, a tax is more predictable.

Key term

natural capital

Natural capital is the stock of natural resources and ecosystems that provide goods and services to people.

Note read

Check your recall[16 marks]

6 written questions. Answer each one in your head or on paper, then open the mark scheme.

  1. 1.Define[2 marks]

    Define the term externality.

    Show mark schemeHide mark scheme

    Model answer

    An externality is a cost or benefit of an activity that falls on people who are not buyers or sellers.

    • 1 mark for stating that it is a cost or benefit of an activity
    • 1 mark for stating that it falls on people who are not part of the transaction
  2. 2.Explain[3 marks]

    Explain why a market with a negative externality makes too much of a product.

    Show mark schemeHide mark scheme

    Model answer

    The producer ignores the external cost, so the price is lower than the social cost. A low price increases demand and output. Society therefore receives more of the product than is best for it.

    • 1 mark for stating that the producer ignores the external cost
    • 1 mark for explaining that the price is lower than the social cost
    • 1 mark for linking the low price to a higher output than society would choose
  3. 3.Calculate[2 marks]

    A quarry’s dust causes 3 currency units (cu) of harm for each tonne of stone. It sells 800 tonnes. Calculate the total external cost.

    Show mark schemeHide mark scheme

    Model answer

    Total external cost = 3 cu tonne−1×800 tonne=2400 cu3\,\mathrm{cu\,tonne^{-1}}\times800\,\mathrm{tonne}=2400\,\mathrm{cu}3cutonne−1×800tonne=2400cu.

    • 1 mark for multiplying 3 cu tonne−13\,\mathrm{cu\,tonne^{-1}}3cutonne−1 by 800 tonnes
    • 1 mark for giving the answer as 2400 cu2400\,\mathrm{cu}2400cu
  4. 4.Compare[3 marks]

    Compare cap-and-trade with a rule that gives every firm the same emission limit.

    Show mark schemeHide mark scheme

    Model answer

    Both limit pollution. Cap-and-trade lets firms trade permits, so those with cheap ways to cut pollution can do more of it. A fixed limit makes every firm meet the same target, which is less flexible but gives a clearer result.

    • 1 mark for stating that both aim to limit pollution
    • 1 mark for explaining that cap-and-trade lets firms trade permits and choose the cheapest way to cut emissions
    • 1 mark for explaining that a fixed limit applies equally to every firm and is less flexible
  5. 5.Evaluate[4 marks]

    Evaluate the use of a pollution tax to reduce environmental harm.

    Show mark schemeHide mark scheme

    Model answer

    A tax gives firms a continuing reason to cut pollution and raises money for restoration. However, it is hard to set a tax equal to the real external cost, because natural capital is difficult to value. Firms may also pay and carry on polluting. A tax works best where many polluters can cut emissions at different costs, but regulation suits severe harm.

    • 1 mark for identifying a strength, such as a continuing incentive or raised revenue
    • 1 mark for identifying a second strength or a clear reason it works
    • 1 mark for identifying a weakness, such as difficulty valuing natural capital or firms paying and polluting
    • 1 mark for reaching a supported judgement about when a tax works best
  6. 6.Outline[2 marks]

    Outline how a subsidy can encourage environmental protection.

    Show mark schemeHide mark scheme

    Model answer

    A subsidy makes an environmentally friendly option cheaper, such as solar panels. Buyers and firms are then more likely to choose it.

    • 1 mark for stating that a subsidy lowers the price or cost of a desired activity
    • 1 mark for stating that this makes people or firms more likely to choose it

Practice this topic

10 quick-fire multiple-choice questions, easy to hard. Tap an answer to see if you're right and the worked explanation. (The written questions with mark schemes are under “Check your recall” above.)

0 right0 of 10 answered

Includes the 2 quick checks in the note above.

3.

Easy·Identify[1 mark]

Identify the example of a subsidy.
Show answer and explanation

Answer: D · Worked explanation

A subsidy is a payment that makes a desired activity cheaper, and a solar panel grant does this. The charge on waste is a tax, which raises a price. The ban is regulation, and the permit limit belongs to a cap-and-trade system.
4.

Medium·Calculate[2 marks]

A tannery’s discharge causes 5 currency units of harm for each tonne of leather. It produces 1200 tonnes. Calculate the total external cost.
Show answer and explanation

Answer: C · Worked explanation

Total external cost equals harm for each tonne multiplied by tonnes made: 5 × 1200 = 6000 currency units. The value 240 comes from dividing 1200 by 5, which is the wrong operation. The value 1205 comes from adding the two numbers instead of multiplying.
5.

Medium·Determine[2 marks]

A producer pays 8 currency units to make each item. Each item also causes 3 currency units of damage to other people. Determine the social cost of one item.
Show answer and explanation

Answer: B · Worked explanation

Social cost is private cost plus external cost: 8 + 3 = 11 currency units. The value 8 is only the private cost and leaves out the damage. The value 24 comes from multiplying the two numbers, which has no meaning here.
6.

Medium·Predict[2 marks]

A government places a pollution tax equal to the external cost on a product. Predict the most likely effect on the product.
Show answer and explanation

Answer: A · Worked explanation

The tax raises the producer’s cost, and at least part of it is usually passed on in a higher price. A higher price reduces the amount buyers want. The idea that the price stays the same ignores that producers normally pass on part of the tax.
7.

Medium·Compare[2 marks]

Compare a pollution tax with a cap-and-trade system.
Show answer and explanation

Answer: D · Worked explanation

A tax charges a fixed amount for each unit, so the quantity released can vary. Cap-and-trade fixes the quantity through the number of permits, and the market sets the permit price. The reversed statement mixes up which quantity each tool controls.
8.

Hard·Predict[2 marks]

A cap-and-trade system allows 1000 tonnes of emissions, with one permit for each tonne. The government cuts the cap to 800 permits. Firms’ demand for emissions stays the same. Predict the most likely result.
Show answer and explanation

Answer: C · Worked explanation

Total emissions cannot exceed the number of permits, so 800 tonnes is the limit. The same demand for fewer permits makes them scarcer, so their price tends to rise. Trading moves permits between firms but cannot create new ones, so emissions cannot stay at 1000 tonnes.
9.

Hard·Identify[2 marks]

A government wants to prevent irreversible drainage of a rare wetland. Identify the most suitable approach and its reason.
Show answer and explanation

Answer: B · Worked explanation

Regulation suits harm that is severe or cannot be undone, because a ban prevents the damage altogether. A small tax allows firms to pay and carry on, so the wetland could still be lost. A generous cap also allows harm, and payments cannot restore a drained wetland.
10.

Hard·Evaluate[2 marks]

A student claims that a pollution tax removes all pollution because firms pay for the harm. Evaluate the claim.
Show answer and explanation

Answer: A · Worked explanation

A tax changes incentives but does not forbid pollution, so firms can pay and continue. Valuing natural capital is also difficult, so the tax may be set too low. The claim that taxes never change prices is wrong, since a tax raises the producer’s cost and usually the price.

Keep going

Next topicHL.c Environmental ethicsPrevious topicHL.a Environmental law

More in Topic HL · HL lenses

  1. HL.aEnvironmental lawNotes · 10 questions· HL only
  2. HL.bEnvironmental economicsNotes · 10 questions· HL only
  3. HL.cEnvironmental ethicsNotes · 10 questions· HL only

All IB Environmental Systems and Societies topics →

Draft: written by Scribe and checked automatically, not yet by a subject reviewer.

Practice questions are original, written by Scribe and checked automatically for correctness.

Topic codes follow the official numbering. Not endorsed by IB Diploma Programme or any exam board.

On this page

0/5 read

  1. 1Markets can ignore costs that fall on other people
  2. 2Social cost is private cost plus the external cost
  3. 3Taxes, permits and subsidies change the price signal
  4. 4Regulation sets limits directly instead of using prices
  5. 5Economic tools have strengths but also clear limits
  6. Check your recall
  7. Practice: 10 questions
All coursesScribeHow it worksPricingPrivacyTerms

Notes and questions are written by Scribe in our own words. Topic codes follow the official course numbering so you can find your place. Not produced or endorsed by the IB, College Board, AQA, OCR, Pearson Edexcel or any exam board.

© 2026 Scribe

Private and social cost of a product

Price or cost (currency units per unit)0246810024681012Quantity (units per month)
  • Demand
  • Private cost
  • Social cost
  • Market output
  • Social optimum