Edexcel A-level Biology A (Salters-Nuffield) · Topic 2 · Genes and Health
2.16 Ethics of genetic screening
Discuss ethical issues linked to genetic screening, explain arguments for and against it, and describe its effects on individuals and society.
1/5Screening can give individuals early and useful information
- Screening can give individuals early and useful information
- Screening also raises concerns for the people tested
- Embryo and pregnancy testing involve disputed moral views
- Screening can affect families and society as a whole
- A good discussion weighs benefits and harms for each group
- Check your recall
- Practice: 10 questions
Part 1 of 5: Screening can give individuals early and useful information
Some inherited disorders can be treated if they are found early. In phenylketonuria, the body cannot break down the amino acid phenylalanine. A newborn blood test detects it, and a controlled diet then protects the baby’s developing brain.
Screening can offer individuals several benefits.
- Early treatment that prevents or reduces harm
- Informed choices about having children
- Time to prepare for a child’s needs
- Closer monitoring of people at higher risk
Key term
phenylketonuria
Phenylketonuria is an inherited recessive disorder in which phenylalanine cannot be broken down properly and builds up in the body.
Part 2 of 5: Screening also raises concerns for the people tested
Despite these benefits, a test result can also cause difficulties. An ethical issue is a question of right and wrong in which the interests of different people may conflict. A person’s autonomy, their right to decide for themselves, depends on a free choice about whether to be tested.
The choice must also be informed. Informed consent means a person agrees to a test after understanding its benefits, risks and possible results. Without this, a person may feel pressured into testing or be unprepared for what they learn.
Results can cause stress, especially when they show risk rather than certainty. Invasive prenatal tests carry a small risk of miscarriage. A false result may bring needless worry or false reassurance.
Key terms · tap one for its definition
ethical issue
An ethical issue is a question about what is right or wrong in which the interests or rights of different people may conflict.
autonomy
Autonomy is a person’s right to make their own informed decisions about their own body and life.
informed consent
Informed consent is a person’s agreement to a procedure or test after receiving and understanding information about its benefits, risks and possible outcomes.

Quick check
One question on the part you just read
Easy
Show answer and explanation
Answer: B · Worked explanation
Part 3 of 5: Embryo and pregnancy testing involve disputed moral views
Some of the sharpest disagreements concern testing before birth. After a positive prenatal result, parents may consider ending the pregnancy. People disagree about the moral status of an embryo or fetus, meaning how far its interests count. Some hold that human life deserves full protection from fertilisation. Others give more weight to the wellbeing of the family.
Pre-implantation genetic diagnosis tests embryos made by in vitro fertilisation (IVF) before one is placed in the womb. Critics fear it could lead towards a designer baby, chosen for traits such as appearance rather than health. Supporters say avoiding serious disease is different from choosing by preference. In the UK, a regulator licenses the conditions that embryos may be tested for.
Key terms · tap one for its definition
moral status
Moral status is the degree to which the interests of a being must be taken into account when deciding what is right.
designer baby
A designer baby is an embryo selected, or genetically altered, so that the child has chosen characteristics unrelated to preventing disease.
Part 4 of 5: Screening can affect families and society as a whole
Results do not stay with one person. A person’s genotype is partly shared with relatives. A result may therefore reveal a risk to a sister, brother or child who did not ask to be tested. Confidentiality is the duty to keep results private, but people may still feel they should tell relatives.
Society faces issues too. Genetic discrimination could occur if insurers or employers treated people unfairly because of their results. Laws and codes of practice restrict how such information may be used.
Screening costs money, so health services must decide how to spend limited funds. If screening reduces the number of births with a disorder, some people with disabilities fear for how society values them. Others point to the suffering that screening can prevent.
Key terms · tap one for its definition
confidentiality
Confidentiality is the duty to keep a person’s genetic information private unless they agree to share it.
genetic discrimination
Genetic discrimination is the unfair treatment of a person because of their genotype or their risk of inherited disease.

Quick check
One question on the part you just read
Easy
Show answer and explanation
Answer: C · Worked explanation
Part 5 of 5: A good discussion weighs benefits and harms for each group
Now that the main issues are clear, the next step is to weigh them. Many people support screening when it is voluntary, informed and backed by genetic counselling, which explains results and choices. Others oppose it when it pressures people or treats disability as a problem to remove.
Benefits and harms of screening for different groups
- Group
- Individuals
- Possible benefit
- Early treatment and informed choices
- Possible harm
- Stress and unwanted knowledge
- Group
- Families
- Possible benefit
- Time to plan and prepare
- Possible harm
- Pressure to share results
- Group
- Society
- Possible benefit
- Less suffering from serious disease
- Possible harm
- Discrimination and changing attitudes to disability
- Group
- Health service
- Possible benefit
- Resources aimed at those at risk
- Possible harm
- Costs that compete with other care
Few ethical questions have one correct answer. A strong answer states the issue, gives arguments on each side and reaches a reasoned judgement.
Check your recall[15 marks]
6 written questions. Answer each one in your head or on paper, then open the mark scheme.
- 1.Describe[2 marks]
Describe two benefits of genetic screening for individuals.
Show mark schemeHide mark scheme
Model answer
Screening can allow early treatment that prevents or reduces harm, as with a controlled diet for phenylketonuria. It can also help carriers make informed choices about having children.
- 1 mark for describing one benefit, such as early treatment that prevents or reduces harm
- 1 mark for describing a second benefit, such as informed choices, preparation or closer monitoring
- 2.Explain[3 marks]
Explain why informed consent is important before a genetic screening test.
Show mark schemeHide mark scheme
Model answer
Informed consent means a person agrees after understanding the benefits, risks and possible results. This protects their autonomy and lets them choose freely. It also prevents people being pressured into a test or being unprepared for the result.
- 1 mark for stating that the person understands the benefits, risks and possible results before agreeing
- 1 mark for linking consent to autonomy or free choice
- 1 mark for stating that it avoids pressure or lack of preparation for the result
- 3.Suggest[2 marks]
Suggest two ways in which one person’s screening result could affect other people.
Show mark schemeHide mark scheme
Model answer
The result may show that relatives could also carry the faulty allele. It may create pressure on the person to tell relatives or cause distress in the family.
- 1 mark for suggesting that relatives may learn they are at risk
- 1 mark for suggesting a second effect, such as pressure to share the result, family distress or effects on family planning
- 4.Discuss[4 marks]
Discuss whether embryos should be tested using pre-implantation genetic diagnosis.
Show mark schemeHide mark scheme
Model answer
Testing lets carrier parents have a child without a serious disorder and avoids ending a pregnancy. However, people disagree about the moral status of embryos that are not used. Some fear it could lead to designer babies, although regulation can limit testing to serious conditions. Overall, testing for serious disease with regulation can be justified.
- 1 mark for giving an argument in favour, such as avoiding a serious disorder without ending a pregnancy
- 1 mark for explaining why this is a benefit
- 1 mark for giving an argument against, such as disagreement about moral status or the risk of designer babies
- 1 mark for reaching a balanced or reasoned conclusion, for example by referring to regulation
- 5.Describe[3 marks]
Describe how society might be affected by widespread genetic screening.
Show mark schemeHide mark scheme
Model answer
Screening could reduce suffering from serious disease but would cost money that could be spent elsewhere. Genetic discrimination could occur if results are misused. Attitudes to disability might change if people feel such lives are valued less.
- 1 mark for describing a benefit, such as less suffering from serious disease
- 1 mark for describing a cost or resource issue, or the risk of genetic discrimination
- 1 mark for describing a change in attitudes to disability
- 6.Define[1 mark]
Define the term genetic discrimination.
Show mark schemeHide mark scheme
Model answer
Genetic discrimination is the unfair treatment of a person because of their genotype or their risk of inherited disease.
- 1 mark for stating that it is unfair treatment of a person because of their genotype or inherited disease risk

Practice this topic
10 quick-fire multiple-choice questions, easy to hard. Tap an answer to see if you're right and the worked explanation. (The written questions with mark schemes are under “Check your recall” above.)
0 right0 of 10 answered
Includes the 2 quick checks in the note above.
EasyIdentify[1 mark]
Show answer and explanation
Answer: A · Worked explanation
MediumIdentify[1 mark]
Show answer and explanation
Answer: B · Worked explanation
MediumIdentify[1 mark]
Show answer and explanation
Answer: B · Worked explanation
MediumIdentify[1 mark]
Show answer and explanation
Answer: D · Worked explanation
MediumIdentify[1 mark]
Show answer and explanation
Answer: C · Worked explanation
HardExplain[2 marks]
Show answer and explanation
Answer: A · Worked explanation
HardIdentify[2 marks]
Show answer and explanation
Answer: B · Worked explanation
HardIdentify[2 marks]
Show answer and explanation
Answer: D · Worked explanation