Edexcel A-level Biology A (Salters-Nuffield) · Topic 5 · On the Wild Side
5.18 How the scientific community validates evidence
Describe how scientists share and check evidence, explain why peer review matters, and outline how theories are validated.
1/5Scientists publish their work so that others can check it
- Scientists publish their work so that others can check it
- Peer review checks the quality of research before publication
- Independent repeats show whether a result can be trusted
- A theory becomes accepted when many tests support it
- Readers should judge a claim by how it was checked
- Check your recall
- Practice: 10 questions
Part 1 of 5: Scientists publish their work so that others can check it
Suppose a team claims that a new medicine lowers blood pressure. Other scientists will want to see the evidence before they accept it.
A scientist starts with a hypothesis, a proposed explanation that can be tested. Experiments or observations then produce data. The data count as evidence once other scientists can examine them.
Results are usually published in a scientific journal. The report gives the method, data and conclusion in enough detail to repeat the work. Scientists also present findings at conferences, where colleagues can question them directly.
Key terms · tap one for its definition
hypothesis
A hypothesis is a testable proposed explanation for an observation or phenomenon.
scientific journal
A scientific journal is a regular publication that prints research reports, usually after experts have checked them.
Part 2 of 5: Peer review checks the quality of research before publication
Journals do not print every report they receive. They first send it for checking.
Peer review is checking by independent experts. The reviewers work in the same field but are not part of the research team. They usually have no stake in the result.
Reviewers judge several things.
- Whether the method was suitable and controlled
- Whether the data support the conclusion
- Whether the sample was large enough
- Whether bias could have affected the results
The editor then accepts the report, asks for changes or rejects it. This filters out poor work and improves the work that is published.
Key terms · tap one for its definition
peer review
Peer review is the evaluation of a research report by independent experts in the same field before it is published.
bias
Bias is a systematic influence, such as a personal or financial interest, that pushes results or conclusions in one direction.

Quick check
One question on the part you just read
Easy
Show answer and explanation
Answer: B · Worked explanation
Part 3 of 5: Independent repeats show whether a result can be trusted
Peer review checks a report, but it does not repeat the experiment. That job falls to other laboratories.
A result is more convincing when other scientists obtain it too. They follow the published method with their own equipment and samples. If they get similar results, the finding has good reproducibility.
Repeating work reduces the chance that the first result was due to chance, error or bias. Testing the same idea with a different method also helps. Agreement between methods builds confidence further.
If repeats disagree, scientists look for the reason. The first team may have made an error, or an overlooked variable may matter. Either way, the disagreement leads to better understanding.
Key term
reproducibility
Reproducibility is the extent to which independent scientists obtain consistent results when they repeat an investigation using the same method.
Part 4 of 5: A theory becomes accepted when many tests support it
A single finding is only the start. Science aims for explanations that survive many tests.
A prediction states what should be observed if a hypothesis is correct. Scientists test predictions with new experiments. If the results match, the hypothesis gains support. If they do not, it must be changed or rejected.
A scientific theory is a widely tested explanation supported by evidence from many independent sources. It explains a wide range of observations and makes testable predictions. The theory of evolution by natural selection is supported by fossils, DNA and observed populations.
Theories remain open to change. New evidence that conflicts with a theory leads scientists to modify or replace it. This willingness to revise is a strength of science.
Key terms · tap one for its definition
prediction
A prediction is a statement of what should be observed if a hypothesis is correct.
scientific theory
A scientific theory is a widely tested explanation that is supported by evidence from many independent sources.

Quick check
One question on the part you just read
Easy
Show answer and explanation
Answer: D · Worked explanation
Part 5 of 5: Readers should judge a claim by how it was checked
Not every claim has been through these checks, so readers need to judge their sources.
A news story or an advert may report a result that has never been peer reviewed. Check whether the work appeared in a journal, and whether other scientists have repeated it.
Useful questions include the following.
- Was the sample large enough and the method controlled?
- Do the conclusions follow from the data?
- Who paid for the research?
- Do the authors have a conflict of interest?
Mistakes sometimes pass through review. When errors or misconduct are found later, the journal may issue a retraction. The paper is withdrawn, and other scientists should no longer rely on it.
Key terms · tap one for its definition
conflict of interest
A conflict of interest is a situation in which a personal or financial interest could influence how research is done or reported.
retraction
A retraction is the formal withdrawal of a published paper because of errors or misconduct.
Check your recall[13 marks]
6 written questions. Answer each one in your head or on paper, then open the mark scheme.
- 1.Describe[2 marks]
Describe how scientists share their findings with the rest of the scientific community.
Show mark schemeHide mark scheme
Model answer
They publish a report of the method, data and conclusion in a scientific journal. They may also present findings at conferences.
- 1 mark for stating that a report with the method, data and conclusion is published in a scientific journal
- 1 mark for stating that findings may be presented at conferences
- 2.Explain[3 marks]
Explain why a report is sent for peer review before a journal publishes it.
Show mark schemeHide mark scheme
Model answer
Independent experts check the method, the data and whether the conclusion follows from them. They can spot errors or bias. This filters out poor work, so published research is more likely to be reliable.
- 1 mark for stating that independent experts check the method, data or conclusions
- 1 mark for stating that errors, bias or unsupported conclusions can be identified
- 1 mark for stating that this filters out poor-quality work or improves quality
- 3.Explain[2 marks]
Explain why other scientists repeat a published investigation.
Show mark schemeHide mark scheme
Model answer
They want to see whether they obtain similar results, which shows the finding is reproducible. This reduces the chance that the original result was due to chance, error or bias.
- 1 mark for stating that they check whether the results can be reproduced
- 1 mark for stating that repeats reduce the chance that the result was due to chance, error or bias
- 4.Outline[3 marks]
Outline how a hypothesis can become a widely accepted scientific theory.
Show mark schemeHide mark scheme
Model answer
Predictions from the hypothesis are tested by experiments. Independent scientists repeat the work and obtain consistent results. Evidence from many independent sources supports it, so it becomes a theory.
- 1 mark for stating that predictions are tested by experiments
- 1 mark for stating that independent scientists repeat the work and obtain consistent results
- 1 mark for stating that evidence from many independent sources supports the explanation
- 5.Suggest[2 marks]
Suggest why a claim in an advert for a food supplement needs more checking than a claim in a peer-reviewed paper.
Show mark schemeHide mark scheme
Model answer
The advert has not been checked by independent experts, so its method and data may be flawed. The company selling the product may have a conflict of interest or bias.
- 1 mark for stating that the advert has not been through peer review
- 1 mark for stating that the seller may have a conflict of interest or bias
- 6.State[1 mark]
State what is meant by a conflict of interest.
Show mark schemeHide mark scheme
Model answer
A conflict of interest is a situation in which a personal or financial interest could influence how research is done or reported.
- 1 mark for stating that a personal or financial interest could influence how the research is done or reported

Practice this topic
10 quick-fire multiple-choice questions, easy to hard. Tap an answer to see if you're right and the worked explanation. (The written questions with mark schemes are under “Check your recall” above.)
0 right0 of 10 answered
Includes the 2 quick checks in the note above.
EasyState[1 mark]
Show answer and explanation
Answer: A · Worked explanation
MediumIdentify[2 marks]
Show answer and explanation
Answer: C · Worked explanation
MediumIdentify[2 marks]
Show answer and explanation
Answer: B · Worked explanation
MediumIdentify[2 marks]
Show answer and explanation
Answer: D · Worked explanation
MediumIdentify[2 marks]
Show answer and explanation
Answer: A · Worked explanation
HardIdentify[2 marks]
Show answer and explanation
Answer: C · Worked explanation
HardEvaluate[2 marks]
Show answer and explanation
Answer: D · Worked explanation
HardIdentify[2 marks]
Show answer and explanation
Answer: B · Worked explanation