Edexcel A-level Biology A (Salters-Nuffield) · Topic 5 · On the Wild Side
5.20 Controversial science and decision making
Explain why some scientific issues are controversial, describe how evidence informs decisions, and outline the part that ethics plays in scientific debate.
1/6Scientific issues become controversial when evidence is incomplete
- Scientific issues become controversial when evidence is incomplete
- People weigh the same evidence differently because of their interests
- Reliable evidence has to meet standards before it guides decisions
- Decision makers balance risks and benefits using the evidence
- Ethics decides what should be done, not what can be done
- Decisions combine evidence, ethics and public views
- Check your recall
- Practice: 9 questions
Part 1 of 6: Scientific issues become controversial when evidence is incomplete
Imagine a new farming method that could raise food production. Some people welcome it. Others worry about harm to wildlife, and each group quotes real data.
An issue is controversial when informed people disagree about it. One cause is uncertainty. The evidence may be limited, short term or based on small samples. Scientists can then reach different conclusions without anyone being careless.
Key terms · tap one for its definition
controversial
A controversial issue is one on which informed people hold strongly opposing views, often because evidence, values or interests differ.
uncertainty
Uncertainty is the degree of doubt about a measurement or conclusion, arising from limited data, variation or measurement error.
Part 2 of 6: People weigh the same evidence differently because of their interests
Even when the data are agreed, groups may still disagree. This is common in public debates about new technology. A person’s values and interests shape which findings seem most important. A company selling a product may stress its benefits, while a campaign group stresses its risks.
Each person or group affected by a decision is a stakeholder. Their priorities often conflict, as the table shows.
Stakeholders may reach different views on the same new technology
- Stakeholder
- Farmer
- Likely concern
- Higher yield and lower costs
- Stakeholder
- Conservation group
- Likely concern
- Loss of habitat and wildlife
- Stakeholder
- Consumer
- Likely concern
- Safety, price and labelling
- Stakeholder
- Government
- Likely concern
- Public health, trade and cost
Media reports add to the difficulty. A headline can present a possible risk as a certain one, or leave out the size of the sample.
Key term
stakeholder
A stakeholder is any person or group that is affected by a decision or has an interest in its outcome.

Quick check
One question on the part you just read
Easy
Show answer and explanation
Answer: C · Worked explanation
Part 3 of 6: Reliable evidence has to meet standards before it guides decisions
Decision makers need a way to judge competing claims. The first test is the quality of the evidence.
Good evidence comes from a sound investigation. It has a suitably large sample, controlled variables and results that others can repeat. Independent experts check it before publication, which is called peer review.
Be careful with patterns in data. A correlation is a link between two variables. It does not prove causation, because a third factor may affect both.
Key terms · tap one for its definition
correlation
A correlation is a statistical association in which two variables change together, whether or not one causes the other.
causation
Causation is a relationship in which a change in one variable directly produces a change in another.
Part 4 of 6: Decision makers balance risks and benefits using the evidence
Good evidence still has to be turned into a decision. This usually means comparing risks with benefits.
A risk is the chance that harm will occur, together with how serious that harm would be. A new drug may cure a disease but cause side effects in a few patients. Decision makers weigh both sides.
Sometimes the evidence is uncertain but the possible harm is serious. The precautionary principle supports acting early in such cases, before the evidence is complete.
Other factors also matter. These include cost, the law and what the public will accept.
Key terms · tap one for its definition
risk
A risk is the probability that a hazard will cause harm, considered together with how serious that harm would be.
precautionary principle
The precautionary principle is the idea that action to prevent possible serious harm need not wait for full scientific proof.

Quick check
One question on the part you just read
Easy
Show answer and explanation
Answer: A · Worked explanation
Part 5 of 6: Ethics decides what should be done, not what can be done
Evidence can show that something is possible. It cannot say whether it is right. That is where ethics enters the debate.
Ethics is the study of what is morally right and wrong. Ethical arguments appeal to fairness, harm, rights and respect for life. Some people judge an action by its consequences, asking whether it produces more good than harm. Others judge it by principles, such as the right to be informed.
One issue can raise a scientific question and an ethical question
- Issue
- Animal testing of a drug
- Scientific question
- Does the test predict effects in humans?
- Ethical question
- Is it right to cause animals harm?
- Issue
- GM crops
- Scientific question
- Does the crop reduce losses?
- Ethical question
- Should humans alter the genes of organisms?
Key term
ethics
Ethics is the set of moral principles used to judge whether actions are right or wrong.
Part 6 of 6: Decisions combine evidence, ethics and public views
Real decisions rarely rest on one kind of argument. Governments and regulators usually follow a series of steps.
- Gather and assess the available evidence
- Consult stakeholders and the public
- Weigh risks, benefits, costs and ethical concerns
- Make a decision, then review it as new evidence appears
Public engagement matters because decisions affect everyone. Open reporting of the evidence and its limits helps people trust the outcome. If new evidence changes the balance of risk and benefit, a rule can be changed.
Check your recall[15 marks]
6 written questions. Answer each one in your head or on paper, then open the mark scheme.
- 1.Explain[2 marks]
Explain why a scientific issue may stay controversial even when scientists agree on the data.
Show mark schemeHide mark scheme
Model answer
Stakeholders have different values and interests, so they weigh the same data differently. One group may stress the benefits while another stresses the risks.
- 1 mark for stating that stakeholders have different values or interests
- 1 mark for linking this to different weighting of risks and benefits
- 2.Give[3 marks]
Give three features of reliable evidence that a decision maker should look for.
Show mark schemeHide mark scheme
Model answer
A suitably large sample, controlled variables, and results that are repeatable or checked by independent experts.
- 1 mark for a suitably large sample
- 1 mark for controlled variables
- 1 mark for repeatable results or checking by independent experts (peer review)
- 3.Explain[2 marks]
Explain why a correlation between two variables does not show causation.
Show mark schemeHide mark scheme
Model answer
A correlation is only a link in which two variables change together. A third factor may affect both variables, so one need not cause the other.
- 1 mark for stating that a correlation is only an association between variables
- 1 mark for stating that a third factor may affect both variables
- 4.Outline[3 marks]
Outline how the precautionary principle may influence a decision about a new technology.
Show mark schemeHide mark scheme
Model answer
If the technology might cause serious harm, action is taken to prevent it. This happens even though the evidence is incomplete. Decision makers also compare the possible risks with the benefits.
- 1 mark for stating that action is taken to prevent possible serious harm
- 1 mark for stating that this happens before the evidence is complete
- 1 mark for stating that risks are weighed against benefits
- 5.Suggest[3 marks]
Suggest why scientific data alone cannot settle whether animal testing of a new drug is acceptable.
Show mark schemeHide mark scheme
Model answer
Data can show whether the test predicts effects in humans. Whether it is right to cause animals harm is an ethical question about values. People hold different ethical views, such as judging by consequences or by principles.
- 1 mark for stating that data can answer only the scientific question
- 1 mark for identifying that right and wrong are ethical questions based on values
- 1 mark for stating that people hold different ethical views
- 6.Name[2 marks]
Name two stakeholders in a decision about a new farming technology.
Show mark schemeHide mark scheme
Model answer
Farmers and consumers (or a conservation group, a business or the government).
- 1 mark for naming one suitable stakeholder
- 1 mark for naming a second suitable stakeholder

Practice this topic
9 quick-fire multiple-choice questions, easy to hard. Tap an answer to see if you're right and the worked explanation. (The written questions with mark schemes are under “Check your recall” above.)
0 right0 of 9 answered
Includes the 2 quick checks in the note above.
MediumIdentify[1 mark]
Show answer and explanation
Answer: D · Worked explanation
MediumIdentify[1 mark]
Show answer and explanation
Answer: A · Worked explanation
MediumCalculate[2 marks]
Show answer and explanation
Answer: B · Worked explanation
MediumIdentify[1 mark]
Show answer and explanation
Answer: D · Worked explanation
HardIdentify[2 marks]
Show answer and explanation
Answer: C · Worked explanation
HardIdentify[2 marks]
Show answer and explanation
Answer: A · Worked explanation
HardIdentify[2 marks]
Show answer and explanation
Answer: B · Worked explanation